Last Sunday night, instead of getting started with my massive workload, I read mangas. Four shoujo mangas. How irresponsible, but I haven't meant to do that actually. So now I say to myself,
I'm sorry, self, to have slack off so much in one night, not get any work done, and have you cram all these acads nonsense now. I know there is no worse form of torture than bury you under that pile of schoolwork. I'm so, so sorry, man.
All right. Now, I will review those mangas, so in a why I could explain why I'd read as much as I did that night without a care for my responsibilities at school.
It was night. Six pm, approximately. And I'd been thinking of starting with my homework, only that, when I turned on my laptop I strayed to mangafox instead. The first title I read was
Ovally Trap. It was an utter waste of time, I had not felt anything while reading the story, more so now, four days later, I have already forgotten about it. I had to Google it so I could remember.
Ovally Trap is a one-shot. In my opinion, making it such is a poor decision on the author's part. Cramming a story into a single chapter without losing substance and using drawings, instead of purely words, is hard. That's why there are stories which won't make sense as one-shots, Ovally Trap is an unfortunate example.
It is a story of a girl who is constantly teased by a guy classmate (Google says the guy is called Tokunaga and she Tanimiya). She's usually annoyed by his antics, that when she chanced upon a magazine article on "How to be Popular," her friends convince her to try it as revenge on Tokunaga -- h
ow exactly is this revenge, I do not know. Maybe she wants to blow him away with her attractiveness, he won't be able to tease her anymore -- yes, that must be it.
<
spoiler > She changes her image and a lot of guys notice her. Except, it wasn't clear how her image changed at all judging from the lack of change in the drawings of her. If it wasn't directly stated in the speech bubbles that the guys thought there was something different about her, I wouldn't have known. Anyways, Tokunaga finally ask her if they could walk home together, to which she said yes. While waiting for him by the school gates, a guy from another class also showed interest in her. Tokunaga showed up, said that he wasn't needed anymore, and walked away. She chased after him, leaving the other guy behind, and told him she likes him. What a surprise. < /
spoiler >
Everything happened so fast, so that I had quite a hollow reaction to everything. But there was one cute page, at least, it's only redeeming quality. Perhaps, it would've worked better with a little more back story.
-
And so I was almost annoyed at the first manga, I had to read another one to forget about the oddness of the first. And this second choice wasn't even any better, in fact, it was much worse. Title:
Otomegokoro (A Girl's Feelings).
One star out of five.
I don't even want to write a synopsis, so here's one from
myanimelist:
Nene is having her own "High School Debut"! In junior high she played volleyball and was not popular. But now things are different. With some makeup and a new hairstyle, she is all set! Teasing her as she attempts to get a boyfriend is her nemesis, Jun. He is amused by Nene's attempts at being fashionable, but in spite of it all, they are good friends. But love can be painful, as Nene finds out when she realizes she is falling for Jun, but he is totally in love with his old first love...
At first, it was Ok, smooth-sailing. Nene met Jun's first love Izumi, without knowing it was she who he was pining for, and they instantly clicked and become somewhat friends. But Nene felt Izumi is someone she doesn't want Jun to meet, but they met anyway, and she her fears were confirmed. Nonetheless, she still supported his love until he finally confessed to Izumi. Up until that point, I still liked the story. <
spoiler > But things went downhill after Izumi turned him down, then started flirting with him when she realized Nene had feelings for Jun. < /
spoiler >
Seriously? I cannot take that kind of conflict seriously. Not when some psycho little drama queen decides to ruin everyone's lives is a story going to be interesting. And so, even the resolution at the end --
I never even thought the characters felt that way, especially Jun!-- seemed meaningless.
This manga was an even greater waste of time that the last one.
The drawing was good though, better than the first.
-
So, yes, I needed another manga. This is why I stay away from shoujo mangas; if not overly sappy, or cliched, they were downright annoying. An excellent shoujo manga is a rare find.
Kimi ga Suki (and the sequel
Kimi ga Suki Plus) wasn't excellent, I didn't like it the way I liked
High School Debut, despite the premise being the same (and even the same as the previous one I'd just read). But it was passable, Otomegokoro's author redeemed herself with this one.
Yet another synopsis from
animelist:
Aki has always liked her basketball club friend, Mase. However, she can’t seem to gather her courage to confess to him. On the day when she finally decides to tell him, she is confessed to by a guy from a different Junior High! A horrible accident follows and Aki finds herself not being able to choose between the two – Mase, whom she truly loves or Koichi, whom she’ll always feel indebted to…
It's horribly cliched, but quite an alright read.
And I believe it needs its own review-post with all the things I have to say about it. Next time, maybe. EDIT: That is because the characters are very much alive. They acted the way real, rational people would have had they been in similar situations.
And because I really like it, and encourage more people to read it, I will not write any spoilers. Besides what I said about the characters, about each one of them being rational, which I think in itself is quite a feat to achieve, they all have impressive attitudes. No one is overly bitchy, pathetic, showy, selfish, annoying. Just really mature adults and they all have acted for the best, even to the point of self-sacrifice. And although it is true that many were hurt because of a simple sacrifice, that things got confusing, it was all worth it in the long run, thanks largely to the characters' levelheadedness and understanding. Most importantly Koichi was able to move on thanks to Aki. If Aki had not stayed, he would not have recovered as well as he did, he would have wallowed on regret and self-pity. So Internet, please don't go blaming Aki.
I give it four stars of five.
Reviews across the net say Otomegokoro's better than this. So, yes, I don't trust the Internet's taste as well as I did.